Order by 2/10 for Valentine's Delivery — Use "VDAY23" for an extra 20% off at check-out

Favorites Set

Favorites Set

Regular price $43.80 $36.00 Sale

There's still time for Valentine's delivery!
Order with standard shipping for 3+ items by 4pm Thursday 2/9, or with Express or UPS Expedited by 4pm 2/10


These are flavors that year-round people tell us how much they love - Cookies and Cream, S'mores, Salted Caramel and Mint Chocolate Chip. These 4 also served as the inspiration for 4 of our most popular ice cream flavors at our shop outside Orlando.

S'mores and Cookies and Cream contain gluten

Marshmallows all have a best by between 2-4 months from cook date, depending on flavor.